A judge partially granted Highland Park Methodist Church’s request for a temporary restraining order blocking the Horizon Texas Conference of the United Methodist Church from using the names “‘Highland Park United Methodist Church,’ ‘Highland Park United Methodists,’ ‘Highland Park UMC,’ ‘HPUMC,’ ‘HPUMC Oasis,’ or any other designation confusingly similar.”
The news comes after Highland Park Methodist Church held a congregational vote in October in which the voting members favored leaving the United Methodist Church after the Horizon Texas Conference of the United Methodist Church filed a lawsuit in August against the church over changes made to the church’s governing documents in 2022.
Following the vote, Matt Tuggle has continued leading worship at 3300 Mockingbird Lane under the name Highland Park Methodist Church, and Bishop Ruben Saenz Jr. of the Horizon Texas Conference of the United Methodist Church appointed longtime assistant to the bishop Andy Lewis as senior pastor for those who want to remain part of the denomination, now worshipping in the Prothro Great Hall at SMU’s Perkins School of Theology.
Highland Park Methodist Church on Nov. 10 filed an application for a temporary restraining order barring the conference from “using the names ‘Highland Park United Methodist Church,’ ‘Highland Park United Methodists,’ ‘Highland Park UMC,’ ‘HPUMC,’ or ‘HPUMC Oasis,’ or any other name or designation confusingly similar to ‘Highland Park United Methodist Church’ or ‘HPUMC,’ in connection with any worship service, ministry, fundraising, website, social-media account, signage, or other public communication.”
“Congregants were uncertain where to meet and which communications were actually from the Church, while donors withheld contributions out of concern that their money might go to Plaintiff. When informed ofthis confusion, Plaintiff moved its competing, identically named congregation even closer literally across the parking lot from the Church while continuing to solicit donations using the Church’s legal name and mark,” a filing from HPMC seeking the TRO read.
The conference, in its filing in response to HPMC argued that the court doesn’t have jurisdiction over ecclesiastical issues and that only United Methodist entities can use “United Methodist” in their names.
“As a matter of United Methodist church law, only United Methodist entities may use ‘United Methodist’ in their names, and the denomination has ecclesiastically determined HP Corporation is not United Methodist. Additionally, the requested injunction would impose an unconstitutional prior restraint on religious speech and assembly by prohibiting the Conference and its congregants from gathering for worship as they deem fit.,” the conference’s filing read.
A judge in a Nov. 18 order partially granted the temporary restraining order blocking the conference from using the names “‘Highland Park United Methodist Church,’ ‘Highland Park United Methodists,’ ‘Highland Park UMC,’ ‘HPUMC,’ ‘HPUMC Oasis,’ or any other designation confusingly similar,” from “soliciting or accepting charitable contributions using the HP Marks or any other confusingly similar designation,” from expressing or implying that the conference’s new congregation is Highland Park Methodist Church or affiliated with it, and from operating the website hpunitedmethodist.org, or any other website that uses the Highland Park United Methodist Church name or logos or similar ones.
The order notes that the conference, or any person, isn’t barred from gathering for worship or operating a congregation “under any non-infringing name.” The order expires at 4 p.m. Dec. 2, unless extended by the court or agreement.
People Newspapers has reached out to Highland Park Methodist Church and the conference for comment and will update as additional information becomes available.
Background on the Lawsuit
The August lawsuit filed by the Horizon Texas Conference of the United Methodist Church, a regional governing body which covers North Texas, stems from changes the 100-plus-year-old church’s leadership made to its governing documents in 2022 and 2023.
Among the changes specifically at issue is the church’s changing its corporate name filed with the Office of the Secretary of State from “Highland Park United Methodist Church” to “Highland Park Methodist Church” in 2022.
The lawsuit further alleges that the church also adopted amended bylaws that year, which “i) remove all references to The United Methodist Church, the Conference, and the Discipline; ii) remove the rights of HP Church members to participate in any matter ‘affecting or involving the Church’; and iii) remove the members’ right to participate in determining the denomination of HP Church, including selection of the Church Council.”
HPMC has said in a statement on its website that the church changed its corporate documents in accordance with guidance in 2020 from Texas courts “on managing church affairs under neutral principles of Texas law,” and that HPMC worked with the conference on the corporate name change. HPMC further stated that the church’s Charge Conference voted unanimously to delegate governance to the Church Council in 1998.
Following the lawsuit, the congregation voted in favor of separating from the denomination after a two-day voting process on Oct. 26 and began worshipping as Highland Park Methodist Church, rather than Highland Park United Methodist Church.
Immediately following the two-day voting process on Oct. 26, the Horizon Texas Conference of the United Methodist Church said in a statement that “a congregational vote does not, by itself, sever a local church’s relationship with the United Methodist Church.”
Conference officials have said a framework under the Book of Discipline that allowed for disaffiliation amid a schism around issues such as the ordination of LGBTQ+ clergy and the performance of same-sex marriages expired on Dec. 31, 2023.
“We will not walk away from you. Our goal remains a vibrant United Methodist church at the corner of Hillcrest and Mockingbird: a congregation governed as a United Methodist church, connected to the wider church and open to all. We will keep pursuing that goal faithfully, patiently and through every proper path available to us. This is not the end of the story,” Saenz previously wrote.
In a statement, the church council had said the bishop’s announcement “changes nothing” for them.
“We will worship as usual with our clergy, including our Senior Minister, Rev. Matt Tuggle at the pulpit – at our Church on the corner of Mockingbird and Hillcrest,” the church council said on Oct. 29. “As we have said many times, we will continue to protect our beloved and incredible clergy including the Rev. Matt Tuggle and the Rev. Paul Rasmussen. They did not choose to be in this situation any more than our Church did, but we are committed to their care, just as they have cared for us.”
Author